Episode List - The Critshow

Here you’ll find the episode page for each and every episode of The Critshow so far, Other Side of the Coin as well as most of the extra and bonus stuff in our feed. (The only thing from our main feed not listed here is our various Let’s Plays.)

If you’re looking for something more specific, you might prefer to see just Other Side of the Coin by season or by game system (keep in mind that the game system page may contain what could be considered spoilers, and enter at your own risk). Or, check out all the bonus stuff we’ve posted separate of Coin.

On each individual episode page you’ll find a synopsis and eventually a transcript (we’re gradually getting caught up with our transcripts, so please bear with us). You’ll also be able to listen to the episode right here in your browser.

December 5, 2023That Dreadful Bell (S5, E70)
November 28, 202328 Minutes (S5, E69)
November 21, 2023At Death’s Door in Silent Springs
November 14, 2023Building a Ghost Train (S5, E67)
November 7, 2023Rain Over the Churchyard (S5, E66)
October 31, 2023Crit or Treat 2023 (S5, E65)
October 24, 2023The Busted Locomotive (S5, E64)
October 17, 2023Cowboys & Kaiju (S5, E63)
October 12, 2023Rapscallion Season 5 Q&A
October 10, 2023Hitting the Ol’ Dusty Trail (S5, E62)
October 3, 2023Everything but the Squeal (S5, E61)
September 26, 2023Little Pig, Little Pig, Let Me In (S5, E60)
September 19, 2023Hogging the Road (S5, E59)
September 12, 2023Casting Pearls Before Swine (S5, E58)
September 5, 2023Shoulder-deep in Trouble (S5, E57)
August 29, 2023A Festival of Meat (S5, E56)
August 22, 2023Under the Gun (S5, E55)
August 15, 2023Research & Development (S5, E54)
August 8, 2023The Broken Bridge (S5, E53)
August 1, 2023The Beheader (S5, E52)
July 25, 2023The Blood of the Father (S5, E51)
July 18, 2023The Father Goroga (S5, E50)
July 11, 2023Into the Hurricane (S5, E49)
July 4, 2023Dubious Friends (S5, E48)
June 27, 2023A Brand New Fleet (S5, E47)
June 20, 2023Rotten Cloth (S5, E46)
June 13, 2023The Shrouded One (S5, E45)
June 6, 2023Run Aground (S5, E44)
May 30, 2023Hunters on the Boardwalk (S5, E43)
May 23, 2023Whistler’s Cove (S5, E42)
May 16, 2023The Voyage of the White Rabbit (S5, E41)
May 9, 2023Battered and Battened (S5, E40)
May 2, 2023Poison and Bone (S5, E39)
April 25, 2023Wreckage On Deck (S5, E38)
April 18, 2023What To Do With Evil Parrots (S5, E37)
April 11, 2023Blood and Gold (S5, E36)
April 4, 2023Smoke and Silver (S5, E35)
March 28, 2023Dead in the Water (S5, E34)
March 21, 2023Crumbling Ships (S5, E33)
March 14, 2023Blood in the Water (S5, E32)
March 7, 2023Empty Kegs (S5, E31)
February 28, 2023The Well of Last Bay (S5, E30)
February 21, 2023Watchers in the Throng (S5, E29)
February 14, 2023A Beast in the Bay (S5, E28)
February 7, 2023Distant Shores (S5, E27)
January 31, 2023The First Step to Peace (S5, E26)
January 24, 2023Shifting Skin (S5, E25)
January 17, 2023The Blood Duel (S5, E24)
January 10, 2023The Invitation (S5, E23)
January 3, 2023Starhold Q&A
December 27, 2022The Spirit of Giving (S5, E22)
December 20, 2022Lying Through the Radio Waves (S5, E21)
December 13, 2022Scanning for Truth (S5, E20)
December 6, 2022One Hour (S5, E19)
November 29, 2022Wonder Twins (S5, E18)
November 22, 2022A Novel Secret (S5, E17)
November 15, 2022Mangled Wires (S5, E16)
November 8, 2022Double Trouble (S5, E15)
November 1, 2022Deviating Passages (S5, E14)
October 25, 2022Crit or Treat 2022 (S5, E13)
October 18, 2022Faraday (S5, E12)
October 11, 2022Gamma’s Green Glow (S5, E11)
October 4, 2022Silver Strings (S5, E10)
September 27, 2022A Shimmer in the Storm (S5, E9)
September 20, 2022Communication Breakdown (S5, E8)
September 16, 2022Featured Podcast: Of Mice and Men and Monsters
September 13, 2022Laughter from the Dark (S5, E7)
September 6, 2022Menace in the Vents (S5, E6)
August 30, 2022The Teal House (S5, E5)
August 23, 2022Smoke and Space Pirates (S5, E4)
August 16, 2022Tramway to Hell (S5, E3)
August 11, 2022The Critshow Live: Gen Con 2022
August 9, 2022Forging Monstrosities (S5, E2)
August 2, 2022Across the Universe (S5, E1)
July 26, 2022Season 4 Q&A
July 26, 2022Further Investigation Part 6
July 19, 2022Further Investigation Part 5
July 19, 2022Further Investigation Part 4
July 12, 2022Further Investigation Part 3
July 5, 2022Further Investigation Part 2
June 28, 2022Further Investigation Part 1
June 21, 2022Jump the Shark
June 14, 2022Dinos and Wastelands
June 7, 2022You’ve Been Poisoned
May 31, 2022So you want to be a Mothman
May 24, 2022Car of a Different Color (S4, E41)
May 17, 2022Frozen Visions (S4, E40)
May 10, 2022Golden Light (S4, E39)
May 3, 2022The Cleansing Stream (S4, E38)
April 26, 2022The Necropolis Below (S4, E37)
April 19, 2022March of the Pallbearers (S4, E36)
April 12, 2022A Devil’s Deal (S4, E35)
April 5, 2022The Dripping Blade (S4, E34)
March 29, 2022Battle in the Canopy (S4, E33)
March 22, 2022At The Pond’s Edge (S4, E32)
March 15, 2022An Embarrassment of Rats (S4, E31)
March 8, 2022Wheels in the Air (S4, E30)
March 2, 2022Country Roads (S4, E29)
February 25, 2022Featured Podcast: Dumb-Dumbs & Dragons
February 23, 2022Bad Things Come in Threes (S4, E28)
February 16, 2022A Breath of Magic (S4, E27)
February 9, 2022A Bed of Leaves (S4, E26)
February 2, 2022Urban Shadows Q&A (Part 2)
January 26, 2022Urban Shadows Q&A (Part 1)
January 19, 2022Aggressive Negotiations (S4, E25)
January 12, 2022Before the Storm (S4, E24)
January 5, 2022Bloodshot Eyes (S4, E23)
December 29, 2021Three Doors Down (S4, E22)
December 22, 2021The Grove of the Silver Wing (S4, E21)
December 15, 2021A Flintlock Surprise (S4, E20)
December 8, 2021A View of the Stars (S4, E19)
December 1, 2021The Silver Cross (S4, E18)
November 24, 2021Safehouses (S4, E17)
November 17, 2021A Crisp Blue Suit (S4, E16)
November 10, 2021The Leaders of Power (S4, E15)
November 3, 2021Out of the Rubble (S4, E14)
October 27, 2021Crit or Treat 2021 (S4, E13)
October 20, 2021The Wrigley Casino, Part 2 (S4, E12)
October 13, 2021The Wrigley Casino, Part 1 (S4, E11)
October 8, 2021The Critshow Live: Gen Con 2021
October 6, 2021Card Sharks Wolves (S4, E10)
October 1, 2021Featured Podcast: Spout Lore
September 29, 2021Archives and Artifacts (S4, E9)
September 22, 2021Wizard’s Duel (S4, E8)
September 15, 2021Feathered Wings and Flaming Hooves (S4, E7)
September 10, 2021Featured Podcast: Ain’t Slayed Nobody
September 8, 2021The Olympus Zoo (S4, E6)
September 3, 2021Featured Podcast: Realms of Peril and Glory
September 1, 2021Fangs in the Gloom (S4, E5)
August 25, 2021The Egg (S4, E4)
August 18, 2021Whispered Plans (S4, E3)
August 11, 2021The Monster’s Capitol (S4, E2)
August 4, 2021Stepping into the Shadows (S4, E1)
July 28, 2021Season 3 Q&A
July 21, 2021Potatoes & Molasses
July 14, 2021Postcard from the Expedition
July 7, 2021The Guy Economy
June 30, 2021Dinos & Lasers
June 23, 2021A Wild Sheep Chase, part 4
June 16, 2021A Wild Sheep Chase, part 3
June 9, 2021A Wild Sheep Chase, part 2
June 2, 2021A Wild Sheep Chase, part 1
May 26, 2021A Week Before the Future (S3, E44)
May 19, 2021Specters in Cell Block Seven (S3, E43)
May 14, 2021Featured Podcast: We Fix Space Junk
May 12, 2021Unexpected Magic (S3, E42)
May 5, 2021Castle in the Catacombs (S3, E41)
April 28, 2021The Shadowed Wood (S3, E40)
April 21, 2021Blood in the Water (S3, E39)
April 14, 2021The Frozen Bridge (S3, E38)
April 7, 2021The Inn that Wanders (S3, E37)
March 31, 2021The Frozen Ghost’s Gale (S3, E36)
March 24, 2021Magic in the Mineshaft (S3, E35)
March 17, 2021The Swiss Cheese Siege (S3, E34)
March 10, 2021Planning for the Future (S3, E33)
March 3, 2021Deals at the Dinner Table (S3, E32)
February 27, 2021Featured Podcast: Dumbgeons and Dragons
February 24, 2021Pizza Party (S3, E31)
February 17, 2021Wreckage (S3, E30)
February 10, 2021Watchers in the Bog (S3, E29)
February 3, 2021Out of Gas (S3, E28)
January 27, 2021The Eye of Ra (S3, E27)
January 20, 2021Mercury Poisoning (S3, E26)
January 13, 2021The Bungalow on the Water (S3, E25)
January 6, 2021Turbulence at 10,000 Feet (S3, E24)
December 30, 2020Network Connectivity Problems (S3, E23)
December 23, 2020Fire and Wine (S3, E22)
December 16, 2020Hoofprints in the Snow (S3, E21)
December 12, 2020Featured Podcast: The End of Time & Other Bothers
December 9, 2020Faces in the Crowd (S3, E20)
December 2, 2020Snowy Mountain Village Blues (S3, E19)
November 25, 2020Double Feature: Part 4
November 18, 2020Double Feature: Part 3
November 11, 2020Double Feature: Part 2
November 4, 2020Double Feature: Part 1
October 27, 2020Crit or Treat 2020 (S3, E18)
October 20, 2020Shattered Portals, Shattered Plans (S3, E17)
October 13, 2020A Handful of Black Hole (S3, E16)
October 6, 2020A View From The Bell Tower (S3, E15)
September 29, 2020The Eye of the Beholder (S3, E14)
September 22, 2020Lost Shaker of Salt (S3, E13)
September 18, 2020Bonus: Perilous Tides Episode 6
September 15, 2020Small Town Living (S3, E12)
September 8, 2020Golden Boxes (S3, E11)
September 1, 202049 Robots (S3, E10)
August 25, 2020The 123rd Floor (S3, E9)
August 18, 2020Behind the Green Door (S3, E8)
August 12, 2020High Security (S3, E7)
August 5, 2020Prisoner Transfer (S3, E6)
July 29, 2020Following the Comet (S3, E5)
July 22, 2020City of Neon Lights (S3, E4)
July 15, 2020In The Ring (S3, E3)
July 8, 2020A Little of the Old B&E (S3, E2)
July 1, 2020Rosebush (S3, E1)
June 24, 2020Season Two Q & A
June 24, 2020Perilous Tides: Episode 5
June 17, 2020Perilous Tides: Episode 4
June 10, 2020Perilous Tides: Episode 3
June 3, 2020Perilous Tides: Episode 2
May 27, 2020Perilous Tides: Episode 1
May 20, 2020The Deathless (S2, E47)
May 13, 2020The Soul Crystal Crisis (S2, E46)
May 6, 2020Siege of the Halifax Theatre (S2, E45)
April 29, 2020When the Morning Comes (S2, E44)
April 22, 2020Kill Switch (S2, E43)
April 15, 2020Broken Arrow (S2, E42)
April 8, 2020Grizzly Tidings (S2, E41)
April 1, 2020The Shrouded Stage (S2, E40)
March 25, 2020Yellow Eyes (S2, E39)
March 18, 2020Escape from the Dark City (S2, E38)
March 11, 2020The Infusion (S2, E37)
March 4, 2020Plans in the Airfield (S2, E36)
February 26, 2020Empty Highways (S2, E35)
February 19, 2020A Night in Chicago (S2, E34)
February 12, 2020Cracked Mirror (S2, E33)
February 5, 2020A Door Left Open (S2, E32)
January 29, 2020End of the Road (S2, E31)
January 22, 2020The Undead Lord (S2, E30)
January 15, 2020A Story of Time (S2, E29)
January 8, 2020The Sandstorm’s Fury (S2, E28)
January 1, 2020Ants Marching (S2, E27)
December 27, 2019Thirsty Sword Lesbians/Girl by Moonlight
December 25, 2019Clearwater’s Well (S2, E26)
December 18, 2019Across the Dunes (S2, E25)
December 11, 2019Playing Their Cards (S2, E24)
December 4, 2019Sunken Ships (S2, E23)
November 27, 2019Death’s Door (S2, E22)
November 20, 2019Eyes of Diamond (S2, E21)
November 12, 2019The Walls of Water (S2, E20)
November 6, 2019The Mysterious Depths (S2, E19)
October 30, 2019Crit or Treat 2019 (S2, E18)
October 23, 2019The Wizard’s Cage (S2, E17)
October 16, 2019Treasure and Blood (S2, E16)
October 9, 2019Split Paths Ahead (S2, E15)
October 2, 2019The City by the Bay (S2, E14)
September 25, 2019The Gleaming Moon (S2, E13)
September 18, 2019The Voyage Begins (S2, E12)
September 11, 2019The Twisted Swamp (S2, E11)
September 4, 2019Creatures in the Dark (S2, E10)
August 28, 2019The Sewer Labyrinth (S2, E9)
August 21, 2019The Hall of Bones (S2, E8)
August 14, 2019The Magic Portal (S2, E7)
August 7, 2019The Cloaked Woman (S2, E6)
July 31, 2019Campfire Clash (S2, E5)
July 24, 2019Goblins at the Gate (S2, E4)
July 16, 2019Flames in the Deep (S2, E3)
July 9, 2019The Ascent (S2, E2)
July 3, 2019The Dungeon (S2, E1)
June 25, 2019Season 1 Recap Part 2
June 18, 2019Season 1 Recap, Part 1
June 11, 2019Facing our Demons (S1, E59)
June 4, 2019Goodbye, For Now (S1, E58)
May 28, 2019The Argonaut (S1, E57)
May 25, 2019Investigate the History: The Halifax Theatre
May 25, 2019The Hero Salad – Episode 1
May 21, 2019The Magnificent Eight (S1, E56)
May 14, 2019The Bat Trap (S1, E55)
May 7, 2019Night Hunt (S1, E54)
April 30, 2019Welcome to the Jungle (S1, E53)
April 23, 2019IPT: Founders in Thrall (S1, E52)
April 16, 2019IPT: Founders Under Fire (S1, E51)
April 9, 2019IPT: Founders Reunited (S1, E50)
April 9, 2019Episode 50 Celebration Questions (S1, E50-Q/A)
April 2, 2019IPT Dossiers: Hair of the Dog (S1, E49)
March 26, 2019IPT Dossiers: Grave Consequences (S1, E48)
March 19, 2019IPT Dossiers: Bridges and Break-ins (S1, E47)
March 12, 2019IPT Dossiers: Guys and Dolls (S1, E46)
March 6, 2019IPT Dossiers: Appalachian Blues (S1, E45)
February 27, 2019The Road to Hell (S1, E44)
February 20, 2019Red Sun and the Witch’s Rose (S1, E43)
February 13, 2019Black Night and the Deathless Man (S1, E42)
February 6, 2019Bright Day and the Dark Maze (S1, E41)
January 30, 2019Finding the Day (S1, E40)
January 23, 2019Cabin in the Woods (S1, E39)
January 16, 2019Face to Face (S1, E38)
January 9, 2019Questions, Deals, and Frozen Fields (S1, E37)
January 2, 2019Slay Ride (S1, E36)
December 26, 2018Winter Winds of Change (S1, E35)
December 19, 2018The Reunion (S1, E34)
December 13, 2018Patreon Preview
December 12, 2018The Penthouse Blitz (S1, E33)
December 5, 2018Betrayal on the 33rd Floor (S1, E32)
November 28, 2018The Art of the Deal (S1, E31)
November 21, 2018Soul Catcher (S1, E30)
November 14, 2018The Stakeout (S1, E29)
November 7, 2018Took Ill on Thursday, Worse on Friday (S1, E28)
October 31, 2018Crit or Treat 2018 (S1, E27 – Part 2)
October 31, 2018Crit or Treat 2018 (S1, E27 – Part 1)
October 24, 2018The Battle for Elnore (S1, E26)
October 17, 2018Preparing for War (S1, E25)
October 10, 2018Into the Woods (S1, E24)
October 3, 2018Might and Magic (S1, E23)
September 30, 2018The Critshow: IPT Outtakes
September 26, 2018Summoned (S1, E22)
September 19, 2018Monument Circle (S1, E21)
September 12, 2018A Divine Plan (S1, E20)
September 10, 2018Live Show: GenCon 2018 (Part 2)
September 5, 2018Sorting the Facts (S1, E19)
August 29, 2018What Dreams May Come (S1, E18)
August 22, 2018Funhouse (S1, E17)
August 17, 2018Live Show: Gen Con 2018
August 15, 2018Celestial Bodies (S1, E16)
August 8, 2018Light It Up (S1, E15)
August 1, 2018Spaced Out (S1, E14)
July 25, 2018The Eye of Horus (S1, E13)
July 20, 2018The Mortician’s Assistant
July 18, 2018Trial of the Unworthy (S1, E12)
July 11, 2018Hunters or Hunted (S1, E11)
July 4, 2018The Truth (S1, E10)
June 27, 2018Something Fowl (S1, E9)
June 22, 2018Live Show: Indy Pop Con 2018
June 20, 2018Lost and Found (S1, E8)
June 13, 2018Not A Vacation (S1, E7)
June 8, 2018Live Show: PCA5
June 6, 2018New Pet (S1, E6)
May 30, 2018Secret Agent Man (S1, E5)
May 29, 2018The Heat (S1, E4)
May 29, 2018Ley Line (S1, E3)
May 29, 2018Impact (S1, E2)
May 29, 2018The Halifax Theatre (S1, E1)